Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Is Classical Music Elitist? Part 3

Continued from

• Is Classical Music Elitist?
• Is Classical Music Elitist? Part 2

To continue this fascinating discussion of the commentary found on The Guardian's web site, it now evolves into a debate between two posters, katyekpay and Maritz. Here is katyekpay's response to Maritz's earlier post:

To katyekpay (Maritz has his own answers I will publish later), I say, yes, Rock music is not Art, and Classical is. Why? Because rock music is too formulaic. There may be an exception or two to the rule, but the general rule of thumb is that rock music consists of music in the range of a very narrow tempo, with four-line stanzas, each four measures long, and confined to a (sorry for the music theory terms here) I-IV-V₇ harmony. Then after either 2 or three verses, there is a bridge, and back to the original form.

How is this different, from, say, a Schubert art song? Schubert's harmonies are far more wide-ranging; instead of the same volume and density of music all the time, we have different vocal colours, different expression on the piano, and much more. It's amazing what you can find on YouTube these days, so let's listen first to the Techno interpretation of the song Erlkönig (that is their characterization, not mine, so if you have a comment about whether this is Techno, please don't ask me to understand the difference--I can distinguish among Mozart, Haydn, Cannabich, Spohr and Stamic, but I don't hear the difference between Techno, House, Trance, and whatever else there is); then to Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau's interpretation of the Schubert setting. Let me ask you, honestly, which is more subtle? Which has more layers? Which is more moving? And which requires more artistry?

katyekpay, I have much, much more to say to you on the other questions, but it will have to wait for another post; I can rant only so much in one day, and I have a book to finish researching.

Continued in:

• Is Classical Music Elitist? Part 4
• Is Classical Music Elitist? Part 5
• Is Classical Music Elitist? Part 6

Author: Cynthia Wunsch

Like this? Want to read more? Don't miss a single post! Subscribe in a reader or receive future posts in your email inbox.

Tags: Classical Music, Performing, Investment: Human Capital, Investment: Social Capital Last modified 14:13 Fri, 18 Dec 2009 by MatthewWynn1995. Accessed 596 times Children What Links Here Share Except where expressly noted, this work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.